Proud member of:

Where is Blue Turtle Cottage?




Greetings from Sunny Anna Maria Island!

Thanks for stopping by!

Like so many people who have visited Anna Maria Island, we knew the minute we left we would be back! We started looking for a place of our own, and soon bought a 2 bedroom condo that we named Blue Coral Condo. We loved our condo, but soon realized that a house with a pool would be better!

When we found Blue Turtle Cottage we knew it was perfect! Steps to the beach and a private pool in a tropical backyard sealed the deal! 

We completely renovated, landscaped and furnished the cottage to make it comfortable and modern. We must have succeeded because we get so many of our guests telling us how magical and special the cottage is!

We love Blue Turtle Cottage, and we love to share it with our guests! Please have a look around and give us a call, write us an email or fill out the inquiry form, we'd love to hear from you.

People say the nicest things… 

Being frequent travelers to AMI, we were extremely thankful to be introduced to Michele's property through a mutual friend. Michele was kind and gracious from the start, prompt in replying to emails, and overall a pleasure to work with. The house is beautifully renovated, the pool is wonderful and was perfect for my girls (1 1/2 and 5 years), and the distance from the house to the beach can't be beat. You literally walk out the front door and within seconds, your toes hit the sand. We truly enjoyed our stay at the Blue Turtle and would highly recommend Michele's property to anyone who is interested!


First off, we love Anna Maria Island. This newly renovated cottage gave my family and I great access to the beach, it's literally a block away! The sunsets didn't disappoint! After our great days at the beach we were able to come back to the cottage and enjoy the pool out back. My kids, 14 & 11, loved it. The cottage was immaculate, and the owner was available, via email, to answer any questions with an immediate response. The beds were super comfy and so were the extra soft sheets. It was great having a TV in every room, and wifi! We truly enjoyed our stay!


First off its brand new! We were super lucky to come across this on such short notice. Every sheet, blanket, pillow, cup, plate you name it, it's new! Nicely stocked and perfectly decorated! My children 8 & 3 loved the pool and looking at the shells on the property! The owner was super easy to deal with! Great experience. Will definitely come back and recommend.


Look no further...!
My husband and I just returned from our 7 night stay at beautiful Blue Turtle Cottage; we wish we were still there and had booked a longer stay.
Restaurants, Walgreens, Publix, souvenir shops are just down the road - nothing is far away.
The cottage is absolutely idyllic, perfect for the beach (which is less than a stone’s throw away!), and the private pool was heavenly when it was too hot to lay out!
Living room and bedrooms so very comfortable and Michele is an absolute pleasure.
Don't look any further, this place is perfect!
Thank you Michele!!!


 Amazing vacation. Beautiful cottage with everything you need. Pool, beach, walking distance to groceries, restaurant, nail salon (a little pampering never hurt). Free island trolley for traveling the island. Owner Michelle is fabulous, always available to assist with any questions. Already planning next visit.


Perfectly positioned Blue Turtle Cottage.
Only 87 steps to the beautiful Gulf Sands ! So convenient to watch AM Sunsets that really are spectacular , great position to walk north and South on the beach .... I did that every day 😝 will certainly stay again next time we venture to AM .


Why book with us?
​We offer unparalleled personal service. We are happy to direct you to local businesses or make suggestions for anything you might need.
Our property is newly renovated and is constantly maintained.
We are always available 24/7 for our guests!